Cognitivism
in Practice
This week in our
Walden class, we were asked to reflect on the strategies of “Cues, Questions, and Advance Organizers” and
“Summarizing and Note Taking” as explained in (Pitler, Hubbell, Kuhn, & Malenoski, 2007) . How do these
strategies relate to cognitive learning theories? In addition, we were asked to
consider how Concept Mapping and Virtual Field trips correlated with both
strategy and theory.
Pitler et al state that the use of
cues, questions and advance organisers focusses on “enhancing student’s ability
to retrieve, use and organise information about a topic” (Pitler et al, 2007, p. 73). This mirrors Orey’s
description (Laureate Education, Inc., 2011) of cognitive learning theories as “information
processing”, and elaboration as activity that “builds numerous connections to
information”. Concept mapping utilises a main question as the starting point
for the map, setting the scene for the hierarchical cascade of concepts, with the
most inclusive or general at the top. This structure can be seen as an advance
organiser, particularly if a skeleton map is used as a starting point. In
addition, the “parking lot” described by Novak and Canas (2008), can be viewed as a set of cues.
A Virtual Field
trip can also act as an advance organizer, particularly because it limits the
range of information the students will experience, based on the links you place
in the field trip. The Virtual Field
trip can also be highly motivating, one of Novak’s (Novak & Canas, 2008) requirements
for meaningful learning to take place. Such a field trip can also facilitate
iconic (image) and archic (sound) learning due to its inclusion of specific
images and sounds relating to the topic.
Summarizing and
note-taking are viewed by Pitler (Pitler et al, 2007, p. 119) as valuable because they enhance
the ability of the students to “synthesize information and distill it into a
concise new form”. In order to be effective at this skill, students must really
think deeply about a concept.
Building a
concept into a map works with long-term memory rather than short term memory,
reinforcing the networks that the brain creates to store information. It utilizes the limited number of “pieces”
(Orey in Laureate Education, Inc., 2011) short term memory can manipulate successfully,
tying them together into what we might view as chunks.
The skills of summarizing and note-taking can harness the
energy created by a Virtual Field Trip due to its connection with episodic
learning and carefully selected informational images, as recommended by Orey. Students use the life-like nature of the
virtual experience to construct their understanding, and then apply this
understanding and engagement with the topic to their summaries.
Taken
together, this information indicates that use of concept maps and virtual field
trips can enhance the understanding and the ability of my students to recall
the information taught and experienced.
After all, “concepts
and propositions are the building blocks for knowledge in any
domain.” (Novak et al, 2008, p. 11)
I found it interesting that
Edutopia, a newsletter I subscribe to, had listed as one of its most popular
blog posts this week one written by Rebecca Alber in 2011. This article speaks
of the importance of scaffolding, and tied very neatly into this week’s
readings. Here is the link:
References.
Laureate Education,
Inc. (Producer). (2011). Program five: Cognitive learning theories [Video
webcast]. Bridging learning theory, instruction and technology.
Retrieved from http://laureate.ecollge.com/ec/default.learn?coureid=5700267&cpurl=laureate.ecollege.com&survey=1&47=2594577&clientnodeid=984650&coursenau=0&bhcp=1 .
Novak, J.D., &
Canas, A.J. (2008). The theory underlying concept maps and how to construct
and use them, Technical Report IHMC CmaptTools 2006-01 Rev 01-2008.
Retrieved from the Institute
for Human and
Machine Cognition Web Site: http://cmap.ihmc.us/publications/researchpapers/theoryunderlyingconceptmaps.pdf .
Robertson, B.,
Elliot, L., & Robinson, D. (2007). Cognitive tools. In M. Orey (Ed.), Emerging perspectives on learning,
teaching, and technology. Retrieved <insert date>, from http://projects.coe.uga.edu/epltt/
Hello Lisa,
ReplyDeleteGreat post!! You provide a great correlation between the instructional strategies, cognitive learning theories, concept mapping, and virtual field trips. I do have one question. Have you ever did a virtual field trip before. If so, how did it go. If not, what would you do it on? I know I haven't yet but I plan to do many in the future. Again, great post!
Craig
Hi Craig,
ReplyDeleteThanks!
No, I have not. I have looked at doing ones before but the internet speed was so slow at school that they did not work. We DID finally manage to do this week's volcano field trip, but it was touch and go as to loading the site. My class did enjoy it, and then I worked with three volunteers at lunch today to complete our spiderscribe map.
I chose natural disasters/volcanoes because my class recently showed a gap in their understanding of what constitutes a natural disaster. I am hoping the concept map activity will help close that gap. It certainly seemed to work well with the group at lunch today, and we will then use the map we made for review with the whole class.
The only thing I do not like about spiderscribe is that there is no way to include the words in the linking arrows like in CMap. Whic one were you trying? Do you have a favourite?
Lisa
Hi Lisa and Craig,
ReplyDeleteI wanted to use the cacoo site but I could not figure out how to make the boxes visable. All I got was text in an invisible box. After about 5 minutes I gave up and switched to spiderscribe. The other choices were blocked at the school where I am currently working.
The whole experiment turned out to be a huge learning curve, much like everything else I am doing. Is it politically correct to refer to students as guinea-pigs? I am trying out so many new ideas on them, I think they are wishing for their regular teacher to return so things can get back to what they consider normal.
I too was wishing to include some linking words on the arrows.
Tracy
Hi Tracy,
ReplyDeleteWhen I asked for volunteers to work on the concept map at lunch I asked for guinea pigs! They didn't seem to mind. I had a lot more volunteers than I wanted!
Lisa
PS So funny to see "Lisa and Craig" as the header for your comment - my brother is Craig too, and for a moment I thought someone who knew us both was blogging!